The boat is twenty minutes out from the harbour in Fujairah when the diver beside Nandor stops talking about the turtle and starts talking about a friend she hasn't spoken to in two years.
She doesn't seem to notice the change. One moment it's the turtle's slow turn under the ledge, the next it's the message she keeps drafting and not sending. Her voice goes thin on the word "sending". She looks at the water instead of at him.
Nandor runs the dive school. Two hours earlier, at twelve metres, this same woman lost her regulator for a moment and came up to him with wide eyes. He held her shoulder, kept his own breathing slow and visible, and waited until hers matched it. It took about forty seconds. He has done it many times, and he's good at it.
On the boat, he does none of that. His hands go looking for a job, coiling a line that's already coiled, and he says "People, eh," with a small laugh, and then he asks whether she'd like to book the night dive. She says maybe. The engine noise fills the rest of the trip.
That evening, rinsing the gear, he thinks about the three customers this year who've told him he'd make a good life coach. He isn't sure what they saw.
Nandor and the diver are composites.
What makes a good life coach?
A good life coach is someone whose behaviour in a session helps the client think more clearly than they could alone. In our experience, three behaviours matter most: leaving the thinking with the client, staying steady when the client feels something strong, and knowing where coaching ends and other help begins. All three can be learned.
Notice what's missing from that list: charm, good advice, an impressive career, a calm voice. Those can help. None of them, on its own, is what makes the hour work for the client.
If you're wondering whether this could be your work, a free call with an RS Method Master Practitioner is where RSCI talks that through with you. The apply page sums up its purpose in one line: "We assess fit on both sides." Ask for a call. Or read on.
What doesn't make someone a good life coach on its own?
A few things get mistaken for the job, often by the people who'd be most suited to it.
Being the one people confide in. Customers telling Nandor their stories on the boat says something real about him: people feel safe near him. But being confided in and helping someone think are different things. Many natural confidants listen beautifully and then, out of kindness, fix.
Giving good advice. Advice can be wise and still take the decision out of the client's hands. We look at the difference between a life coach, a mentor and a consultant in what is coaching.
A successful career. Senior experience can earn a client's respect in the first session. It can also tempt a life coach to steer the client toward the route that worked for them.
A credential. An ICF credential tells clients that a life coach has met a recognised standard, and that matters. It can't tell anyone how a particular session will go.
None of these is a disadvantage. Each simply sits beside the job rather than being the job.
Which three behaviours show up in a good life coach's sessions?
These are the three we look for, in our own words. Each one leaves traces you could point to afterwards.
1. The thinking stays with the client. The life coach's questions are built from the client's words. Silences are left for the client to fill. When the client reaches a decision, it's theirs, phrased their way. A sign it's missing: the client leaves with the life coach's plan.
2. The life coach stays steady when the client feels something. Tears, anger, a voice going thin. A steady life coach neither rushes to soothe it nor changes the subject. The ICF names this in its 2025 Core Competencies, which we read at coachingfederation.org and checked on 9 November 2026: "Develops and maintains the ability to manage one's emotions". A sign it's missing: a joke, a reassurance or a new topic arriving the moment feeling does.
3. The life coach knows where coaching ends. They keep to the agreed time and focus, say "I don't know" when they don't, and help a client reach a doctor or a mental health professional when what's in front of them needs clinical care. The same ICF document lists "Seeks help from outside sources when necessary". A sign it's missing: a life coach who tries to handle everything.
Of the three, the second is the one that surprises people most, because it doesn't look like a skill. It looks like nothing happening.
Why is Nandor steady in the water and not on the boat?
Because at twelve metres he knows exactly what to do, and on the boat nobody has told him.
Underwater, the panic belongs to the diver and the procedure belongs to him. His breathing is a tool, and he uses it. On the boat, the diver's voice going thin on "sending" reaches something in him that no training has touched. His hands go looking for a job the way they did when he was younger and sadness came into a room he didn't know how to stay in. The laugh and the night-dive question aren't choices. They're the fastest way back up to the surface.
That's why customers are right and wrong about him at once. They felt how steady he is. They didn't see where the steadiness stops.
A good life coach isn't someone whose hands never reach for a rope. It's someone whose old reactions have been met and cleared, so that a client's sadness can be in the room without the life coach heading for the surface. For Nandor, that would mean the reach for the rope no longer coming when someone's voice goes thin. How he'd answer the diver then is his to find out.
That's the order RSCI holds to with every trainee, because the second behaviour can't be taught as a technique alone: the practitioner is transformed before the practitioner is trained. How a new life coach's doubts fit into that is something we look at in imposter syndrome as a new life coach.
If you recognise your own version of the boat, it may be worth bringing to the free call as you weigh up where to train. The Master Practitioner will look with you at whether RSCI fits. Find a call time.
How can you score yourself on three behaviours?
This takes about thirty minutes and a sheet of paper. Use real moments from the last month, at work or outside it, when someone brought you something that mattered to them.
A note of care before you start. This self-check is for anyone weighing life coaching as work. It isn't therapy or medical care. If you're under a doctor's or therapist's care, keep it up, and if you're in recovery, your programme and the people beside you in it stay right where they are. If remembering a moment brings up something heavy, put the sheet down and talk to someone you trust or a professional.
- Draw three rows. Label them: the thinking stayed with them; I stayed steady; I knew my limits.
- Give each row a score from 1 to 5. Go on instinct. You'll check it in a minute.
- Write one real example beside each score. A specific person, day and sentence, with names left out. "I'm generally a good listener" doesn't count.
- Write what you said or did next. Your actual words, as best you can remember them, not what you'd say now.
- Read the example against the score. If the example doesn't support the number, change the number.
- Circle the lowest row. Then write down what happened in your body just before the moment you described there.
- Keep the sheet for a month. Add a second example to each row when one turns up, and see whether the scores hold.
In our experience, step 5 often moves at least one score down. That isn't bad news. A low score backed by a true example is more useful than a high score backed by a hope, and it gives you something real to talk about when you're choosing a training.
Could RSCI be where you become that life coach?
That depends on fit, and fit runs both ways. Three things hold for everyone who trains with us.
- Work on yourself, as well as on technique. Our training page lists who RSCI is for, and one line reads "You are prepared to experience the work personally." The second behaviour depends on it.
- Correction, given live. The same list includes "You value live practice and correction." The three rows on your sheet are the kind of thing supervised practice brings into view.
- A clear answer on fit before you begin. The apply page puts it this way: "If the fit isn't right, your RS Method Master Practitioner will say so directly." The ICF route is part of what you'd discuss. The ICF-accredited education inside our programmes is designed, delivered and certified by the Institute of Coaching and Mentoring (IICM), an ICF-accredited organisation. The ACC and PCC credentials are awarded only by the ICF.
Whatever score you gave yourself today, this is the work a good life coach is trained for. To witness. To hold. To walk them home.
A lawyer, from the method's case notes: years of internal conflict resolved in minutes through a deep identity shift.
That shift was the lawyer's own, and no two people's work runs the same course.
The way into RSCI starts with a free conversation with the Master Practitioner. Book it on our apply page.
Robert Simic, training the next generation.
P.S. Keep the sheet with your three rows somewhere you'll see it. When you're ready to ask whether RSCI is where those rows get trained, the free call on our apply page is where that conversation starts.