← The Journal · The skills that hold up in the room

How to set goals in coaching: when the goal on the form isn't the client's yet

How to set goals in coaching: what ICF's agreement competency asks, how to tell a borrowed goal from the client's own, and a three-rewrite exercise to try.

"Be promoted to senior manager by the end of June."

That's the line the client wrote on the intake form, in the box marked "What would you like from our work together?" It's tidy and dated. It would pass any goal-setting checklist Jelani has ever seen.

He reads it back to her at the start of their first practice session, in a small meeting pod on the ground floor of a tower in Jumeirah Lake Towers, and asks if that's still right.

"Yes," she says. "That's it."

Jelani is in his first months of life coach training, and he feels the relief of a session with a clear target. He writes it at the top of a fresh page, underlines it, and asks how she'll know she's getting closer.

She answers every question well. She has a timeline, two allies and a list of skills to build. Twice, though, she mentions her old team lead, now a director: he asked about the promotion again on Friday, and he'd been a senior manager by thirty-two. And once, describing the role, her voice goes flat in a way it doesn't when she talks about the training workshop she ran last month for new joiners.

In their third session, she says it out loud. "I'm not sure I want the job. I'm sure I want to have got it."

Jelani and his practice client are composites.

How do you set goals in coaching?

Start with the client's own words, then find out whose goal it is before you make it precise. Ask what reaching it would give them, agree how you'll both recognise progress, and keep checking it as the work moves. In our experience, the first goal a client names is often a first draft, written for someone else's approval.

Precision still matters. A goal both of you can recognise is how a coaching engagement keeps track of whether it's working, and clients deserve that clarity. The order matters, though. Ownership first, measurement second.

Thinking of training as a life coach yourself? An RS Method Master Practitioner offers a free conversation on that question: whether our institute suits you, and which programme would. It runs on Google Meet and takes twenty to forty minutes. Set up the conversation. Or read on.

What does ICF ask of goals in coaching?

ICF doesn't treat goals as a separate competency. They sit inside competency 3, Establishes and Maintains Agreements, in the 2025 ICF Core Competencies (coachingfederation.org, checked on 9 November 2026). The competency's definition speaks of "clear agreements about the coaching relationship, process, plans and goals", and three of its behaviours carry most of the weight for goal setting:

  • "Partners with the client and relevant stakeholders to establish an overall coaching plan and goals"
  • "Partners with the client to identify or reconfirm what they want to accomplish in the session"
  • "Partners with the client to define or reconfirm measures of success for what the client wants to accomplish in the coaching engagement or individual session"

Two things stand out. The verb is always "partners". The life coach doesn't set the goal, and doesn't simply accept it either. And the word "reconfirm" turns up twice. ICF expects a goal to be checked again, at the level of the whole engagement and in each session.

There are two layers here. The engagement goal belongs in your written agreement, and our coaching agreement template has a place for it in the client's own words. The session goal is agreed at the start of each hour, and our guide to coaching session structure looks at how to hold it without being ruled by it.

How can you tell a borrowed goal from the client's own?

Not from the wording. A borrowed goal can be as well written as any other. In our experience, these signs show up more often in the way it's spoken about.

Another person's name keeps arriving. A parent, a manager, a spouse, a peer who got there first. The goal comes with an audience.

The voice changes. It goes flat on the goal and comes alive somewhere else, as it did when Jelani's client talked about her workshop.

"Should" outnumbers "want". Listen for how often the client says what they should be doing next, and how rarely they say what they'd like.

The measure is someone else's reaction. "So he stops asking" or "so they take me seriously" is a goal about another person's behaviour, and the client can't control it.

It arrived finished. A goal with a date, a title and a number, written before the first conversation, has often been rehearsed for someone else for years.

None of these proves the goal is borrowed. They're reasons to ask, gently, before you build a plan on it.

Why do life coaches accept the first goal they're given?

Because a clear goal feels like proof that the session is going somewhere, and the life coach is often the one who needs that proof most.

Go back to Jelani's first page. The moment his client said "That's it", something in him unclenched. He wrote the goal down and underlined it, and the underline felt like a receipt: evidence that this hour had a point, that he was doing coaching properly, that no one watching could fault him. With the receipt in hand, he stopped listening for anything that might make it void. The flat voice and the director's question on Friday both went past him.

That relief belongs to the life coach, not the client. If a trainee's own need to be seen doing it right sits close under the surface, every tidy goal will feel like rescue, and they'll take it. For Jelani, the shift would come when that need settles at its root, so that an unclear first session stops feeling like a test he's failing and starts feeling like the work.

RSCI builds its training on that order. The practitioner is transformed before the practitioner is trained. Whatever hunger for a receipt a trainee brings gets worked on during training, well before a paying client hands them a goal.

Recognise that relief? Mention it when we speak. On that free conversation, our Master Practitioner looks with you at which programme, if either, fits the life coach you want to become, and at whether now is a good moment to begin. Pick a time that suits you.

How do you rewrite a goal until it belongs to the client?

Try three rewrites of one goal. It takes about twenty minutes of a first or second session, and it works with any goal a client brings. Keep one sheet of paper between you, so the client can see every version.

  1. Write the first version exactly as given. Their words, their date, their number. Don't improve it.
  2. Ask what having it would give them. "Suppose it's the end of June and it's done. What does that give you?" Write the answer underneath as the second version, again in their words.
  3. Ask the quiet question. "If nobody else ever found out you'd done this, would you still want it?" Let the silence run. Then ask them to write the third version themselves.
  4. Read all three aloud, slowly. Ask which one they feel in their body as theirs. Don't suggest an answer.
  5. Only now, make it precise. Ask how they'll know it's moving, which is ICF's measure of success, and agree a first marker with a date.
  6. Write the chosen version into your agreement. Note the date and that it's open to revision.
  7. Plan to reconfirm it. Agree when you'll look at it together again, such as the fourth session.

With Jelani's client, the third version read: "Spend more of my week teaching people, and find out whether that can be my job." The promotion might still be part of it. It just isn't the whole of it any more.

One boundary before you try it with a client. Goal work is coaching, so this isn't therapy or medical care and never stands in for either. Any treatment a client already has carries on unchanged, and anyone in recovery stays with their recovery programme and the people supporting them. If a goal conversation uncovers something heavy that stays with someone, such as low mood that has gone on for weeks, suggest they see a doctor or a mental health professional.

Could RSCI be where you learn to hold a client's goal lightly?

Three things help a life coach hold a goal without grabbing it, and each is part of how we train.

  1. A training that starts with your own material. Our method page describes it in one sentence: "The cohort surfaces your own unresolved material." A trainee's need for a tidy target is part of what gets looked at.
  2. An admission conversation about the route, not a test. One of the questions our apply page puts to that call is "Which pathway fits the practice you're building?" The free call weighs that with you, and whether RSCI is right for you at all; it isn't a checklist you have to pass.
  3. An ICF route built into the programmes. RS Method Coach comes with Level 1 of the ICF education, toward the ACC. RS Method Complete carries Level 2, toward the ACC first if you wish, or toward the PCC as your hours grow. The ICF-accredited education inside our programmes is designed, delivered and certified by the Institute of Coaching and Mentoring (IICM), an ICF-accredited organisation. The ACC and PCC credentials are awarded only by the ICF.

There's no rush in the decision either. In the apply page's words, "Most applicants take a week to sit with the decision before they enrol." The first step is the free call, and you'll find it on our apply page.

A goal is a client's way of pointing. The life coach's job is still the one we train for. To witness. To hold. To walk them home.

Talya Whitaker, in her own account of the RS Method: "There are no words for how this has changed my life, changed every cell of my being."

Robert Simic, training the next generation.

P.S. The best goal Jelani's client wrote was the one she found on the third try. If you'd like to talk about training for that kind of patience, the free call starts on the apply page.

Questions

What people also ask.

01 How do you set goals with a coaching client?

Start with the client's own words, then check whose goal it is before you make it precise. Ask what having it would give them, agree how both of you will recognise progress, and revisit it as the work goes on. The goal belongs to the client, not to the life coach or the form.

02 What does ICF say about goals in coaching?

The 2025 ICF Core Competencies place goals inside competency 3, Establishes and Maintains Agreements. Its behaviours include partnering with the client to "establish an overall coaching plan and goals" and to "define or reconfirm measures of success" (coachingfederation.org, checked on 9 November 2026).

03 Should coaching goals be SMART?

A measurable goal helps both of you see progress, so precision has its place. In our experience it works best as the last step, after the goal has been tested for ownership. A borrowed goal can be made perfectly measurable and still not be the client's.

04 Can a coaching goal change during the engagement?

Yes. Clients often find the goal they arrived with was a first draft. Name the change out loud, agree the new goal together, and update your written agreement so both of you have the current version.

Your next step

The path into RSCI begins with a free conversation with an RS Method Master Practitioner. No pressure, no obligation. We assess fit on both sides.

Apply, book a free call →

Share this guide

LinkedIn X Copy link
Link copied
Keep reading

Read it slowly. The deeper standard is not in a hurry.